Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 14

Thread: spare revolver cylinders

  1. #1
    RSiegel is offline
    Team:
    Genl Wm T Sherman's Bodyguard
    Member
    8846V
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Maine
    Posts
    51
    Region:
    Midwest - Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana

    spare revolver cylinders

    I'm currently reading the book "The Cavalry at Gettysburg" by Edward Longacre and in describing, on page 59, the equipment carried by Union cavalrymen, he states that the average trooper carried a saber, a carbine and "one or two revolvers with removable, preloaded cylinders". Is this a verified fact? I thought this was just in the movies.

    Rich

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Deep Southern Maryland
    Posts
    815
    Region:
    Potomac - Virginia, Maryland and Delaware
    I think it's pure Hollywood Hokum. Never heard of it in wartime accounts. And it's worth noting two things:

    First, revolver cylinders were often serial numbered to the gun. Only one cylinder per gun.

    Second, Colt cased sets did not include a spare cylinder...and if they didn't, you can bet that the average issue sidearm didn't, either.
    Support the USIMLT! Help your fellow Skirmishers go for the gold! www.usimlt.com

  3. #3
    Jim Wimbish, 10395's Avatar
    Jim Wimbish, 10395 is offline
    Team:
    8th Regiment Virginia Volunteers
    Member
    10395V
    Join Date
    May 2004
    Location
    Clarksburg, MD
    Posts
    722
    Region:
    Potomac - Virginia, Maryland and Delaware
    The quote from Longacre's book is a bit confusing. The predominant revolvers of the war were the Colt and Remington and you certainly could remove the cylinders on both of them. I can't imagine soldiers riding around with their revolvers in their holsters and with the loaded cylinders elsewhere. Both revolvers were designed to be loaded with the cylinder in place using paper cartridges. and I would expect that was the norm. I would imagine that the only time that the cylinder was removed was for cleaning. Revolvers were kept loaded and capped with the cylinder rotated so that a cap was not under the hammer. I agree with Mike, no one was issued extra cylinders, only one per revolver.
    Jim Wimbish

    Member of NSSA since 2000



  4. #4
    Curt's Avatar
    Curt is offline
    Team:
    Visitor (non-N-SSA Member)
    Member
    NA
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    260
    Region:
    Midwest - Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana
    Hallo!

    It would appear as though the author has not done his research, or worse yet done it at what the Civil War Community calls Farb or lower level Mainstream reenactments.
    Although rare even at more historically-challenged events, the practice of a spare loaded cylinder is a "reenactorism."
    Especially when reenactors fail to understand that revolver ammunition was typically factory or arsenal made paper or foil-type commercial conical ball cartridges that came in packets typically with drilled out wooden blocks to protect them.. and not loose powder in a flask and a handful or cast round balls.

    Much of the preloaded cylinders fantasy/notion comes out of Clint Eastwood in the 1985 "Pale Rider" with his belt of holstered cylinders for his Remington revolver. Or incorrect on-line resources such as this quote:

    "Typically, soldiers armed with revolvers carried several pre-loaded cylinders so that they could replace their spent cylinder with one that was ready to fire."

    Were spare loaded cylinders true, on would expect to find them in Research and Documentation. They are NOT found in ANY:

    1. Primary reports, descriptions, accounts, diaries, or letters home.
    2. Any CW Period cavalry manual that while usually describing anything and everything never mention spare cylinders or how to use them.
    3. Period images of cavalrymen with them.
    4. Manufacturer records and contract terms for arms plus parts. (For example, Colt supplied smallish "X" number of certain spare parts for armorer-type "field' repairs.)
    5. Unit inspections and inventories of firearms, accoutrements, and equipment on hand and present.
    6. Issuance receipts/records
    7. Arms requisition papers.

    One exception, but not Federal, is that some more "irregular' cavalry units such as Mosby's or Quantrill's either for the romantic image or truly for the added sustained firepower, are documented for sometimes having more than one revolver on their person or horse. But, they appear not have bothered with swapping cylinders.

    Curt

    PS

    Some more "legitimate" but still wrong opinions pop up with the Remington cylinder arbor and loading lever changes between misinterpreted as to facilitate swapping cylinders. One of the complaints against Colt revolvers was the barrel attachment 'wedge" that was "easily' lost by the soldier while cleaning, and why Colt added somewhat of a retaining screw safety catch of sorts. Colt did not fix that until 1871.

    Beal's 1858 revolver had a cylinder that was removed by having to lower the loading lever and then taking the arbor or shaft completely out.

    Elliot at Remington designed a change for that weakness that went into the Remington M1861 Army and Navy. Elliot's idea allowed the cylinder arbor to come out without having to lower the loading lever (ramrod). Obviously this did not solve the problem of dropped and lost cylinder arbors, so Remington changed it for their M1863 NM Army and Navy (incorrectly Hobby termed the "M1858 Remington") so that when in its normal position that the cylinder arbor can pulled to free the cylinder without it having to come all the way out or off/loose.)
    Last edited by Curt; 11-03-2014 at 05:49 PM.
    Curt Schmidt
    Formerly 17 years a Sherman's Bodyguard
    Married to a descendant of Senator John Sherman's wife

  5. #5
    jonk is offline
    Team:
    Genl Wm T Sherman's Bodyguard
    Member
    12999
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Posts
    1,106
    Region:
    Midwest - Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana
    The way I see this is, it's possible, even likely that at some point, some soldier on his own choice did this. But think about it; what's more useful, a second whole loaded revolver (picked up on the battlefield or a personal purchase) or just a loaded cylinder? If you were going to carry anything, it would be the whole thing.

    Besides which, as pointed out already, depending on the gun, freeing the cylinder could be anything from 'a little effort' to 'major PITA'. In fact, I'd wager if I had premade paper cartridge, I could load them in about as fast as it would take to swap cylinders.

    However, based on your quote, the author isn't absolutely wrong. You said: and "one or two revolvers with removable, preloaded cylinders".
    1. Cavalrymen often did have revolvers.
    2. The cylinders are removable.
    3. They were preloaded going into battle.

    Unless he specifically says 'one or more CYLINDERS for swapping out with empties,' he's technically correct, if unnecessarily misleading.

  6. #6
    Dave Fox is offline
    Team:
    Visitor (non-N-SSA Member)
    Member
    NA
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    Hendersonville, N.C.
    Posts
    318
    Region:
    Visitor
    Early Colt Patterson arms were sometimes offered with a spare cylinder. I recall from the 1950s a Patterson revolving rifle with a spare cylinder with leather waist belt and fitted cylinder pouch. Truly in 55 years of research and collecting I've never otherwise heard of use of spare cylinders, tho' some very few civilian transitional weapons were fitted with a percussion and an interchangable metallic cartridge cylinder.
    Think about it: swapping cylinders would involve, having disabling an otherwise useful donor revolver (likely belonging to a jealous government), whilst on a fractious horse and in the heat of combat, juggling a revolver, separate barrel assembly (or arbour), and two cylinders, all the while keeping the critter pointed in the right direction and just staying on it. If one had the leisure to do all that and in the correct order, reloading the weapon conventionally wouldn't have been that much more complex.
    Last edited by Dave Fox; 11-03-2014 at 07:42 PM.

  7. #7
    Muley Gil is offline
    Team:
    34th Battalion Virginia Cavalry
    Member
    3020V
    Join Date
    May 2004
    Location
    Southwest Virginia
    Posts
    1,676
    Region:
    New England - New York, Connecticut, New Jersey and Massachusetts
    Kin you imagine dropping a pre-loaded, pre-capped cylinder?
    Gil Davis Tercenio
    # 3020V
    34th Battalion, Virginia Cavalry
    Great, great grandson of Cpl Elijah S Davis, Co I, 6th Alabama Inf CSA

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Huntsville
    Posts
    3,733
    Region:
    Deep South - Georgia, Louisiana, Tennessee, Mississippi and Texas
    Besides which, as pointed out already, depending on the gun, freeing the cylinder could be anything from 'a little effort' to 'major PITA'. In fact, I'd wager if I had premade paper cartridge, I could load them in about as fast as it would take to swap cylinders.
    I'm pretty sure you could swap out a cylinder in a Remington faster than loading and capping it. But odds are they still did not do it.

    Kin you imagine dropping a pre-loaded, pre-capped cylinder?
    This is what I was thinking. Even if you had pre-loaded cylinders, it would be awfully risky to keep them capped. And if you aren't going to keep them capped, what would be the advantage anyway if you have to swap the cylinder and then try to fiddle out 5 or 6 pistol caps and get them in position in the supposed heat of battle? I can hardly do it at the firing line.

    Steve

  9. #9
    John Holland is offline Moderator
    Team:
    44th NY Volunteer Infantry
    Member
    00973V
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    2,871
    Region:
    Northeast- New York
    If I recall correctly, the only real documented use of a second cylinder was by the Pony Express. This was done to have extra shots available without adding the weight of a second revolver. The second cylinder was not meant to be changed while traveling on horseback, but rather at a way station if necessary.

    JDH

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Sherman's Kitchen, GA
    Posts
    980
    Region:
    Deep South - Georgia, Louisiana, Tennessee, Mississippi and Texas
    Colonel Jack Coffee Hays and his Second Texas Regiment of Texas Rangers (having been federalized as part of the U.S. Army) arrived at Vera Cruz on October 17, 1847. Just two days later the first consignment of 394 of the 1,000 Colt Walker “six-shooter” revolvers as had been ordered were delivered at Vera Cruz and issued to the Rangers. Another 180 revolvers were issued to Captain Walker’s company (Company C), and more than a month had passed before a second consignment of 500 revolvers arrived and were issued. Initial planning called for the issue of two pistols to each mounted soldier, along with a single powder flask, bullet mould, and a combination tool for disassembly and cleaning. These were typically stored in pommel holsters mounted either side of the saddle pommel for ease of access and weather protection.

    Many of the Walker Colt revolvers were subsequently lost in service, and in one single battle in which Truitt’s company lost some ten revolvers—the battle of Sequalteplan (now Zacualtipan) was situated about 75 miles northeast of Mexico City in the mountains (in the State of Hidalgo) was a battle that lasted barely ten minutes! Recently a Walker Colt revolver that had been carried by a Private Sam Wilson of Company D was sold at auction for US$920,000. Of the 976 revolvers issued to the five companies of Hayes’ Texas Rangers, at war’s end we know of only 409 that were returned to the government, nearly 300 of which were returned for repairs due to a ruptured cylinder. Of the 220 issued to Company A, only 39 are known to survive, together with 27 of the 204 issued to Company B, 37 of the 219 issued to Company C, 26 of the 218 issued to Company D, and 18 of the 115 issued to Truitt’s Company E. Of some 1091 sold in private sales to civilians only 16 are known to have survived.

    Unlike the records of the Civil War, not only do we know for a fact just who was issued these revolvers we also know who lost them and how many were lost, as well as how many exploded in use. In Truitt’s company, we know the following named individuals lost one or more of their revolvers:

    Pvt. James Chandler (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter at battle of Sequalteplan, Feb 25, 1848;

    Pvt. Cleveland Coffee (C. Ashton’s Co E, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter, cost $30;

    Pvt. Asa Dial (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter;

    Pvt. William Fields (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter at Sequalteplan;

    Pvt. James Hall (Co E, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter;

    Pvt. William Hammock (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter at Sequalteplan;

    Pvt. Prince B. Hawes (Ashton’s Co E, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter (died at Mexico City, Dec 15, 1847);

    Pvt. Dennis Hays (C. Ashton’s Co E, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter, cost $30;

    Pvt. Oliver Lathrop (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter and 1 rifle (died at Mexico City, Apr 8, 1848);

    Pvt. Hezekiah McKelvy (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost three pistols with holsters and housings;

    Pvt. R. W. McMullen (Handley’s Co, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter;

    Pvt. Nathan B. Phillips (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost two six-shooters at Sequalteplan;

    Pvt. John Powers (Co E, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter;

    Pvt; John Roberts (Co E, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter;

    Pvt. Felix Scott (Handley’s Co, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter;

    3rd Corporal Jacob Sessum (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost two six-shooters;

    Pvt. William H. Smith (C. Ashton’s Co E, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter, $30;

    Pvt. Irvin Stanfield (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter, $30;

    1 Lt Amos Strickland (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), two six-shooters unavoidably exploded (resigned Nov 30, 1847 at Jalapa, Mexico);

    Pvt. Andrew Stumpf (C. Ashton’s Co E, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter;

    1st Corporal James Thomas (Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost two six-shooters, $30 each and accoutrements (died Dec 8, 1847 at Puebla, Mexico);

    Major Alfred M. Truitt (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost two six-shooters in skirmish with guerillas, March 1847 (elected Major of the Regiment, Oct 26, 1847);

    Pvt. Andrew Jackson Truitt (A.M. Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost one six-shooter at Sequalteplan;

    2nd Lt Thomas F. Tucker (Truitt’s Co, Second Texas), lost two six-shooters at Sequalteplan.

    Andrew Jackson Truitt (1819-1874) was younger brother of Major Alfred Marion Truitt (1817-1864), the regimental Quartermaster of Hays’ Second Regiment, and Major Truitt was subsequently elected in 1861 as the Quartermaster of the 28th Texas Cavalry, C.S.A. and afterwards served as Quartermaster General for the State of Texas, 1864. The Truitts were my great-great-grandfather’s nephews.
    First Cousin (7 times removed) to Brigadier General Stand Watie (1806-1871), CSA
    1st Cherokee Mounted Rifles | Principal Chief of the Cherokee Nation 1862-66

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 1
    Last Post: 03-30-2013, 02:34 PM
  2. Conversion cylinders
    By 54thvareb in forum Wanted/For Sale Items
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 06-29-2011, 10:11 PM
  3. Ball 1858 Remington revolver cylinders
    By 54thvareb in forum Small Arms
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 12-28-2009, 10:50 AM
  4. Anyone spare a Zouave?
    By Oregon Bill in forum Wanted/For Sale Items
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 09-25-2009, 10:06 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •