Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: Revolver conversion cylinders-- good, bad or meh?

  1. #1
    Jim Barber is offline
    Team:
    110th Ohio Voluneer Infantry
    Member
    5821
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Grove City, OH
    Posts
    235
    Region:
    Midwest - Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana

    Revolver conversion cylinders-- good, bad or meh?

    I'm a terrible shot with my revolver, a nice, accurate Rogers and Spencer. I always intend to practice with it, but by the time I'm done with my other guns, I think about all the fussing around I'll go through just to load the d@mn thing, and it goes home, sad and unfired. I literally did not practice at all with it last season, and it showed. For years I've seen and wondered about various manufacturers' conversion cylinders-- most if not all are 45LC, plus those in 38spl for 36 cal revolvers. Having the convenience of bringing actual, primed & ready cartridges to the range, and firing the same gun (or one identical in weight and shape, anyway) as that used in revolver competition seems like a great idea.

    Any of y'all have much experience, good or bad, with these things? First and foremost, can you attain accuracy comparable to a regular percussion revolver like a Remington or R&S? Any fussy fitting necessary to get decent timing? Or are you better off just buying a gun that comes as a converted model, like the ones Taylors & Co sells?

    Lotsa questions! General feedback or specifics are all appreciated. Winter well, spring is just around the corner.

    Thanks!
    Jim B.
    Grove City, OH

  2. #2
    Jim_Burgess_2078V is offline
    Team:
    15th Connecticut Volunteer Infantry
    Member
    2078V
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Bull Run Battlefield
    Posts
    355
    Region:
    New England - New York, Connecticut, New Jersey and Massachusetts

    Revolver Practice

    Can't comment on the conversion cylinders as I don't have any. I shoot my Pietta Remington only twice a year - spring and fall nationals. I even won a first place 50 yard revolver medal (Sharpshooter class) at this past fall national. While I don't practice with the Remington, I do practice regularly with other modern pistols and revolvers, .22 caliber and up. While practicing with the revolver one uses in competition is always a good thing, any handgun practice is also beneficial.

    Jim Burgess, 15th CVI

  3. #3
    bobanderson is offline
    Team:
    1st Michigan Infantry
    Member
    12291
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Howell, MI
    Posts
    831
    Region:
    Northwest Territory - Michigan, Ohio and Indiana

    Trick is in the loads

    I have a conversion cylinder that fits my Tom Ball Remington. I found when I tried shooting 45 Colts loaded with traditional bullets, the point of impact was much higher than with round balls fired from the original cylinder. This was caused by the weight difference of the projectiles. Since I did not want to change the sights to accomodate 45 Colts, I started loading metallic cartridges with the same black powder charge and round balls. In this way, I found the accuracy and ease of loading to be everything I needed to be able to practice.
    The only drawback for me was the indoor range I use in the winter doesn’t allow black powder. I’m now working up a load with a small charge of smokeless powder (W231) and a .454 round ball lubed with liquid alox. Initial tests showed promise, but be careful using too small a charge in such a large case. I had some squib loads that wouldn’t clear the barrel.
    Bob Anderson
    Ordnance Sergeant
    Company C, 1st Michigan Volunteer Infantry
    Small Arms Committee

    "I won't be wronged. I won't be insulted. I won't be laid a hand on.
    I don't do these things to other people, and I require the same from them."
    - John Wayne in "The Shootist", 1976

  4. #4
    Chris Sweeney is offline
    Team:
    44th NY Volunteer Infantry
    Member
    11847
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    450
    Region:
    Northeast- New York
    Bob;

    Consider using Trail Boss powder instead of 231
    Chris Sweeney

  5. #5
    Jim Brady Knap's Battery is offline
    Team:
    Knap's Battery, Pennsylvania Artillery
    Member
    2249v
    Join Date
    May 2004
    Location
    Gettysburg, Pa.
    Posts
    637
    Region:
    Allegheny - Maryland, Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Virginia
    I agree. Trail Boss has worked very well for me in several handguns including a 1911. One caution, do not sneeze when you have an open container of the stuff or you'll have a snow storm of little grey donuts floating around. The stuff weighs nothing but takes up a lot of space and 5 grains comes to the base of the bullet in a 45 Colt.
    Jim Brady
    2249V
    Knap's Battery


    CUM CATAPULTAE PROSCRIBEANTUR TUM SOLI PROSCRIPTI CATAPULTAS HABEANT

  6. #6
    bobanderson is offline
    Team:
    1st Michigan Infantry
    Member
    12291
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Howell, MI
    Posts
    831
    Region:
    Northwest Territory - Michigan, Ohio and Indiana
    Quote Originally Posted by Chris Sweeney View Post
    Bob;

    Consider using Trail Boss powder instead of 231
    Thanks, Chris. I shot it today (the post reminded me) and got good accuracy with 8 grains of W231 but there was a bunch of soot that kept tying up the cylinder pin.

    Maybe Trail Boss will shoot cleaner?
    Bob Anderson
    Ordnance Sergeant
    Company C, 1st Michigan Volunteer Infantry
    Small Arms Committee

    "I won't be wronged. I won't be insulted. I won't be laid a hand on.
    I don't do these things to other people, and I require the same from them."
    - John Wayne in "The Shootist", 1976

  7. #7
    Jim Barber is offline
    Team:
    110th Ohio Voluneer Infantry
    Member
    5821
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Grove City, OH
    Posts
    235
    Region:
    Midwest - Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana
    Gents,

    Thanks for all the info. In the R&S I've been shooting .457 round balls. They do get "sized down" a bit by the cylinder upon loading.

    Now I'm wondering if I won't need to move down a bit in size-- like Bob mentioned using a .454 in his Ball Remington cartridges-- so they'll fit both the 45LC case and so the finished cartridges will drop into the conversion cylinder itself. Lots to think about!

    Also, if anyone has a Rogers and Spencer (Euroarms-compatible) conversion cylinder (or the whole revolver) they need to get rid of cheap, give me a shout! I happen to be cheap. And poor, monetarily speaking. But that's another discussion.

    Cheers!

    Jim B.
    Grove City, OH

  8. #8
    Curt's Avatar
    Curt is offline
    Team:
    Visitor (non-N-SSA Member)
    Member
    NA
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    260
    Region:
    Midwest - Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana
    Hallo!

    I got on the conversion cylinder fad, er bandwagon, a few years ago. But while only one experience is not a good indication or opinion, I did not like mine.

    I got a Pietta Remington NM1863 Army, and a Kirst cylinder for it. It would not "fit" and would have required some gunsmithing work to go it in.

    I sold it off and got a pair of M1860 Army conversions and a pair of M1871/72 Open Tops... and sold off the Pietta and cylinder unfired.


    Curt
    Curt Schmidt
    Formerly 17 years a Sherman's Bodyguard
    Married to a descendant of Senator John Sherman's wife

  9. #9
    Chris Sweeney is offline
    Team:
    44th NY Volunteer Infantry
    Member
    11847
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    450
    Region:
    Northeast- New York
    I bought a used Uberti repro 1875 Remington in 44/40. It was actually cheaper than a conversion cylinder, and the gun wasn't stamped "blsck powder only" so I felt better about using smokeless loads. Felt just like a New Model Army. Only down side was getting used to the weird 3 click cocking.
    Chris Sweeney

  10. #10
    Muley Gil is offline
    Team:
    34th Battalion Virginia Cavalry
    Member
    3020V
    Join Date
    May 2004
    Location
    Southwest Virginia
    Posts
    1,676
    Region:
    New England - New York, Connecticut, New Jersey and Massachusetts
    I have a .45 Colt conversion for my Ruger Old Army. It will shoot 3" groups @ 25 yards all day long.
    Gil Davis Tercenio
    # 3020V
    34th Battalion, Virginia Cavalry
    Great, great grandson of Cpl Elijah S Davis, Co I, 6th Alabama Inf CSA

Similar Threads

  1. Do reproduction revolver cylinders work in originals???
    By Bruce Cobb 1723V in forum Small Arms
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 05-08-2017, 06:55 PM
  2. spare revolver cylinders
    By RSiegel in forum Small Arms
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: 11-07-2014, 02:58 PM
  3. Conversion cylinders
    By 54thvareb in forum Wanted/For Sale Items
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 06-29-2011, 10:11 PM
  4. Ball 1858 Remington revolver cylinders
    By 54thvareb in forum Small Arms
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 12-28-2009, 10:50 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •